Elsie Green cannot decide which of her two suitors to marry. When she reads Nathaniel Hawthorne's short story "Feathertop", she dreams that she is its heroine Polly Goodkin, and this leads to her final decision.
Sarah
Elsie Green / Polly Goodkin
Henry Green
Captain Dick Green
Tom Green
Ward Roberts
Percy Morleigh / Feathertop (as John Reinhard)
